Endoscopic sleeve gastroplasty (ESG) differs from Laparoscopic sleeve gastrectomy (LSG).
ESG (Endoscopic Sleeve Gastroplasty) is promoted and advocated as a low-risk, equal alternative to the Laparoscopic Sleeve Gastrectomy, but it is not.
Anatomically speaking:
Endoscopic Sleeve Gastroplasty is an endoscopic procedure performed under general anesthesia. During this procedure, a specialized endoscope is inserted through the mouth into the stomach. Multiple plastic “H”-type anchors are used to create a fold in the stomach, thereby reducing its size. No part of the stomach is removed. Initial limited weight loss occurs as the patient feels full after consuming small volumes of food. This effect resembles what happens with the lap band and gastric balloon, and we know how the story ends with those.
LSG is performed laparoscopically with incisions on the abdomen under general anesthesia. Seventy-five to eighty-five percent of the stomach, along its greater curvature, is removed, eliminating the part of the stomach that produces the Ghrelin hormone, which controls and modulates hunger. This is why patients feel fuller with a smaller volume of food and experience significantly reduced hunger.
Results:
Please read the fine print
The summary results indicate
“Our results suggest that ESG is safe and effective for the treatment of obesity, with durable
long-term results for at least up to 5 years after the procedure. “
When you look at the details of the results, however, it states:
“At 5 years, mean TBWL was 15.9% (95% CI, 11.7-20.5, p < .001) and 90 and 61% of
patients maintained 5 and 10% TBWL, respectively.”
This means that five years after ESG, 90% of the patients have only lost 10% of their TBWL (total body weight loss), and 61% would have lost 10% of their TBW (Total Body Weight).
This serves as an illustration of how actual outcomes are obscured within the fine print, resulting in a lack of attention from individuals seeking the optimal outcome devoid of perceived risk. The same principle applies to the ongoing discourse regarding GLP-1 medications. The genuine risk associated with ESG and PLG-1 is that patients have undergone alterations to their anatomy and physiology without demonstrable results. Several years into contemplating a treatment promising sustained outcomes, we find that the alterations have increased the overall risk.
As a surgeon, I encourage people to always ask questions and demand that scientific proof be provided. I am not opposed to progress; considering the nature of our practice, we have witnessed and have unrgone significant evolution over the past 30 years, transitioning from performing open cases necessitating a hospitalization period of 4 to 6 days to performing the same cases laparoscopically and robotically in some cases outpatient procedures.
I have frequently been asking what staples are used in sleeve gastrectomy. A stapling device is used with sleeve gastrectomy. This device comes in different shapes and sizes for different bowel thicknesses and applications. However, they all function the same way. The staple cartridges (the part of the stapler that is replaced after each use with a new one) are selected based on the thickness of the segment of the bowel that needs to be stapled and divided.
The stapling and dividing take place simultaneously. The sampler deploys six rows of staples and cuts between them, leaving three rows on one side and three on the opposite side. With the sleeve gastrectomy, this means that the sleeve stomach that is left has three rows of staples, and the segment of the stomach that is removed also has three rows of staples.
Questions that are frequently asked:
1-Can I have a CT or an MRI done? Yes, The titanium staples are safe for both CT and MRI.
2-What are they made from? The staples are made of titanium and alloys, which are non-reactive and safe.
3-How big are the staples? Different staples are of different sizes, mainly in the mm range; see the tip of the pencil in the image for the relative size.
Gastrointestinal (GI) Bleed following weight loss surgery is rare but does require knowledge of the particular bariatric surgical procedure the patients has and how to proceed with diagnostics to fully evaluate the situation. Acute or chronic gastrointestinal bleeding can cause anemia in patients. However, Anemia may also be caused by nutritional deficiencies (iron, vitamin , minerals), Kidney disease, bone marrow disease and others. The work-up for anemia following weight loss surgery follows a routine protocol. If there is an evidence of bleeding from intestine (bloody emesis, bloody bowel movement, “tar” like black bowel movements) then the diagnostic work up would include an upper and lower endoscopy.
Endoscopic Procedures:
Upper endoscopy Esophagogastroduodenoscopy (EGD): evaluates the esophagus, stomach and a limited area of the duodenum past pyloric valve.
Normal Anatomy
Lower endoscopy Colonoscopy or coloscopy: evaluates the rectus and the entire colon.
Between these two tests, there is still a considerable amount of the small bowel that is not accessible or visualized with endoscopic procedures. For the small bowel, examination Capsule endoscopy is an option in an intact GI tract. Patients who have had Gastric bypass RNY or the Duodenal Switch, the large segments of the small bowel can not be visualized or examined with capsule endoscopy.
RNY Gastric Bypass
Duodenal Switch Two Anastomosis
SADI-S Single Anastomosis Duodeno-ileal - Sleeve
Patients who have had Duodenal Switch, Gastric Bypass and SADI – S would need a tagged red cell scan or CT angiography if GI bleed is suspected in areas of the small intestine that are inaccessible by endoscopic procedures.
There are differing opinions, based on a broad set of scientific publication, wether or not gallbladder should be removed at the time of weight loss surgery. Obviously, Cholecystectomy is a stand alone general surgical procedure that is often performed due to gallstones and/or gallbladder disease with a variety of symptoms. However, the focus of this blog will deal with Bariatric Surgery and Cholecystectomy.
Rapid weight loss can increase a patients chance of forming gallstones. This rapid weight loss can be as little as 3-5 pounds per week. Weight loss surgery can increase your risk for gallstone formation. Several of the common thought processes the mechanism of this is, obesity may be linked to higher cholesterol in the bile, larger gallbladders, high fat diet and larger abdominal girth.
Gallbladder, Duct and Duodenum
When a patient is having the Duodenal Switch (DS) Bariatric operation, or having a revision of a failed gastric bypass to the DS, I always remove the gallbladder. This is because there isn’t an anatomical route to utilize endoscopic procedure for an ERCP should the need rise.
In the case of a patient undergoing Vertical Sleeve Gastrectomy, if there are any indications or complaints of abdominal pain then an ultrasound is done. If there are findings of gallstones or other disease of the gallbladder, then a cholecystectomy is performed at the same time as the Sleeve Gastrectomy.
Common_Cystic-Duct
Clipped_Cystic_DuctandArtery
In my opinion, every patient having the Gastric Bypass (RNY) should also have the gallbladder removed because of the anatomical limitations after surgery that prevents the use of ERCP if needed. Some clinicians will place the patient on a long term medications to reduce the chance of gladstone formation after surgery, which themselves have side effects limiting the compliance in most patients.
Bile reflux gastritis has been recognized as a significant cause of dyspepsia in a subset of patients. This patient group set does not respond to the standard treatment (not expected to) and some get improvement with the treatment of H.Pylori infection if one is diagnosed at the time of upper endoscopy and biopsy.
Inflammation and Foveolar hyperplasia are some of the findings that can be seen endoscopically. This and other findings have all been documented in the literature. An article published in 2005, reported over 40% incidence of Foveolar hyperplasia in patient with bile relax.
It is been noted that bile causes the thickening of the mucosa lining of the GI track. This is called Foveolar hyperplasia when the mucosa of the stomach is noted to be thicker with more numerous and deeper folds.
Foveolar Hyperplasia- Bile Reflux Gastritis
The treatment for this is reduction and prevention of bile reflux to the stomach, in some cases this can only achieved by surgical diversion of the bile from the stomach. Additional information on Bile Reflux and the surgical treatment can be found here.
We’ve created a helpful map and parking diagram for our new Pasadena, CA office location. It also has a general layout of the Huntington Memorial Hospital Campus and Pre-operative intake and testing area. We hope that you find it helpful on your next visit to see Dr. Ara Keshishian, General and Bariatric Surgeon.
Map and Parking Dr. Keshishian's office
Dr. Ara Keshishian has performed more than 2,000 Duodenal Switch procedures, thousands of Sleeve Gastrectomies and more than 500 revisions from other Weight Loss Surgeries such as RNY Gastric Bypass, Adjustable Gastric Band, and Sleeve Gastrectomy to Duodenal Switch as well as General Surgical cases over the last 18 years of private practice.
